How to get your estate agency recommended by AI search

A homeowner asks ChatGPT, “Which estate agents should value my house in Cheltenham?” Does your agency appear?

That’s the challenge of AI Visibility. Your Google ranking isn’t the whole picture. AI tools also need reliable information before they can mention your business.

Here’s how to improve your chances.

How do ChatGPT and Google decide which agents to mention?

There’s no universal league table. Answers change with the question, location, sources and platform.

ChatGPT search can use search partners and current web information to answer local questions. Google AI Overviews draw on Google’s search systems and may show supporting links. Gemini is a separate Google AI product, so don’t assume it will give exactly the same recommendations as AI Overviews.

You can’t buy a guaranteed organic mention. Instead, make your agency easier to find and assess through accurate records, genuine reviews and evidence of expertise.

Start with an AI Visibility check

First, check what AI tools say about your agency.

Open fresh chats in ChatGPT and Gemini, then search Google. Ask questions local sellers and landlords might use:

  • “Which estate agents specialise in period homes in Cheltenham?”
  • “Who should I ask to value a three-bedroom house in my town?”
  • “Which letting agents manage properties in my area?”

Don’t mention your agency’s name initially. Then search by name to check its description and contact details.

Record the question, date, platform, agencies mentioned and sources cited. Repeat tests, because answers vary and Google doesn’t always display an AI Overview.

That’s your baseline, not a definitive ranking.

Make your business details consistent everywhere

Different phone numbers or old addresses across listings confuse clients and make your agency harder to identify.

Check your agency’s name, address, telephone number, website and opening hours across your site, Google Business Profile, Bing Places and relevant local or property directories.

For multi-branch agencies, give each genuine branch its own accurate details. Don’t create pretend locations simply to target more towns. Make it clear which nearby areas each branch serves.

Look beyond directories, too. A genuine mention on a local newspaper, chamber of commerce or community organisation website can help people find independent evidence that your agency operates locally. Prioritise relevant, trustworthy mentions over bulk directory submissions.

Google’s own Business Profile guidance says complete, accurate information helps with local search. It identifies relevance, distance and prominence as the main local ranking factors. That’s guidance for local results, not a published formula for AI recommendations, but keeping your information correct is a sensible place to start.

Give reviews a proper role in AI Search Optimisation

Reviews give prospective clients evidence of your service.

Ask clients for honest reviews after completing a sale, letting or management milestone. Don’t offer rewards for positive comments, and don’t try to script what people say.

Respond professionally to praise and criticism. If several reviews mention good communication, realistic valuations or effective landlord management, that gives potential clients something more specific than a claim that your service is ‘outstanding’.

Google confirms that reviews and ratings can influence local prominence. AI tools may also encounter review information through sources they retrieve, but that doesn’t mean every platform uses the same reviews or awards them a fixed score.

Focus on a steady record of genuine feedback, not a sudden burst of suspicious five-star ratings.

Write answers an AI tool can use and check

Your agency website should answer the questions that influence instructions, not just promote properties.

For example, a page titled “How do you value a house in Cheltenham?” could explain sold prices, current competition, condition and local demand. Give a direct answer first.

Other useful questions include how your lettings service works, what happens at a valuation and which postcodes your branches cover.

Add a short FAQ section to the relevant service page. Put each question in a clear heading and answer it in the first sentence before adding detail. This helps readers get a quick answer and gives search tools straightforward text to interpret.

Keep answers short enough to grasp quickly, but specific enough to be useful. Support claims with genuine local examples, dated market observations or named sources such as Rightmove and HM Land Registry when relevant. Don’t invent figures or imply that an individual result reflects the entire market.

This is practical AI Search Optimisation – making trustworthy information easy to understand and reference. It isn’t a trick for forcing your name into an answer.

What is schema – and do you need it?

Schema is a way of labelling information in your website’s code so search engines can recognise what it means.

Think of it as adding clear labels to a filing system. Rather than leaving a search engine to guess whether an address belongs to your branch, LocalBusiness structured data can identify the business name, address, telephone number and opening hours.

Ask your developer to check that your structured data matches the page. Google’s Rich Results Test can spot errors.

However, schema isn’t a secret route into AI answers. Google explicitly says there is no special AI Overview schema requirement. Clear, accurate content comes first.

How to rank in AI Overviews – don’t overlook access

First, make sure search tools can read your pages.

Google says a page must be indexed and eligible for a search snippet to qualify as a supporting link in AI Overviews. OpenAI says websites seeking inclusion in ChatGPT search should allow its OAI-SearchBot crawler.

Ask your website developer to check both, along with any security settings that might block legitimate crawlers. You don’t need to learn the technical details yourself, but you should know whether your site is accessible.

These checks support eligibility, not guaranteed selection. Google’s AI Overviews and Google Maps also serve different purposes, so ranking well in one doesn’t promise a mention in the other.

Track recommendations – then track enquiries

Run the same set of realistic questions each month. Note whether your agency appears, which competitors feature and whether the answers contain errors.

Inspect cited sources for outdated listings, missing details or unclear services.

Also ask new valuation leads how they found you. Someone may discover your agency in an AI response and then search for your name directly, so website referral reports won’t capture every influence.

Our earlier article, Is your estate agency website ready for the age of AI search?, covers the wider website foundations. This checklist focuses on what you can test and improve today.

Make your agency easier to recommend

You can’t control AI recommendations. But you can make your location, services and track record easier to verify.

Agent Extra helps independent agencies strengthen their AI visibility for estate agents alongside local SEO. If you want to understand where your agency stands and what to improve, book a call to discuss your goals.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my agency appear in Google AI Overviews without ranking first in search?

Yes. Google AI Overviews can include links to pages that aren’t the top organic result for a particular search. Google uses several systems to find material relevant to the question, and the supporting sources may differ between queries. Being indexed and eligible to appear in Search is necessary, but it doesn’t mean your page will be selected.

Does ChatGPT use Google reviews to recommend estate agents?

ChatGPT may find publicly available reviews or business information through sources used in a search, but OpenAI hasn’t published a rule saying Google review scores determine which estate agents it recommends. Reviews remain valuable because prospective clients read them and because they contribute to Google’s local search signals. Treat them as evidence of service quality, not a guaranteed AI ranking technique.

Do I need to buy an AI visibility tracking tool?

No. You can begin with a simple spreadsheet and a set of realistic questions tested across ChatGPT, Gemini and Google. Record the answers and sources so you can spot changes over time. A paid tracking service may become useful if you run several branches or need more frequent reporting, but it won’t replace accurate information and good content.

What should I do if an AI tool gives the wrong details about my agency?

First, check whether the error appears on your own website, Google Business Profile or a third-party listing. Correct inaccurate information at its source and use the platform’s feedback option where available. Keep a record of the misleading answer and check again later. Updates may take time to appear, and an AI tool may still make mistakes despite accurate public records.

Generate New Instructions

We help sales and letting agents generate new motivated instructions.